Thread 3

Truth or
Consequences

What can design do for a
world on fire?
Impending climate collapse. Growing inequalities. Late-stage capitalism. According to both survey and interview responses, the current state of affairs weighs heavily on the minds of designers. Most want to do their part to help a world in crisis and are questioning the truth of design’s role: can it be a vehicle for change or is that belief a mere distraction from the consequences we’ll one day face? As one respondent put it, “Is this the best we can do?”

INDEX

3.1

The Awareness Brand-Aid

3.2

WHEEL OF CONSUMPTION

3.3

DESIGNING FOR CONSEQUENCES

3.1

The Awareness
Brand-Aid

“ARE WE MAKING A DIFFERENCE OR IS THIS PERFORMATIVE ACTIVISM?”

If the designer is a mediator of communication, then part of their role is to organize information to be accessible to many different kinds of people. One respondent believes that designers “do have an important role in society: to help people understand and connect to important global challenges.” And this ability to drive awareness is thought to be its own superpower. Historically, design played a role in many social movements: from the memorable pink triangle of Act Up, to the radical graphic design and printmaking of Emory Douglas (a visual legacy that lives on in the Movement for Black Lives).

DESIGN ACTIVISM THROUGH HISTORY

But when the context shifts from the streets to the feed, respondents feel that designing for awareness may simply add to the noise. Is it enough to pledge allegiance to a cause by crafting a poster of it? In the current state of affairs, many respondents are skeptical that sharing a viral protest graphic equals getting work done.
#BLACKLIVESMATTER BLACK SQUARE TAKEOVER

#BLACKLIVESMATTER BLACK SQUARE TAKEOVER

Designing for awareness gained traction as a way to share information about social causes through feed-friendly carousel posts. By the end of 2020, social media was littered with infographics touting the same visual logic of millennial DTC brands — colorful gradients, playful illustrations, and whimsical typefaces — designed to make you stop scrolling and start reading. But as the carousels surged, many began to question their intentions and outcomes. When movements like Black Lives Matter become a design challenge in a field that’s predominantly white (1.3), even good intentions to bring awareness may be misguided. When does information-sharing become virtue-signaling? What’s the line between promoting causes and boosting personal brand? As the instant gratification of going viral became a cycle in itself, many questioned if such slideshows were as impactful as the emoji rounds of applause suggested. When algorithmic approval and personal publicity began overshadowing real, on-the-ground action, we lost sight of what it meant to organize. Distracted by pleasing palettes, the oversimplification of complex issues and slips of misinformation are too often overlooked.
Overwhelmed with urgency and the realities of contribution, designers posit that designing for awareness could be part of the problem. When asked what object represents design today, many mentioned a bandaid. If our world feels like it’s collapsing, designers worry that their efforts are a quick fix to surface problems — a bandage that’s bound to break.
BANDAID

BANDAID

3.2

WHEEL OF CONSUMPTION

“[I’M WORRIED ABOUT] THE ABSOLUTE
IMPOSSIBILITY TO DETACH DESIGN FROM
CAPITALISM.”

While design’s relationship to activism is in flux (3.1), its relationship to brands has never been stronger. Respondents are proud that “now more than ever, design is taken seriously on the world stage.” But a global platform comes with great responsibility, and designers feel conflicted that their work is channeled into selling more of the stuff that we already have so much of. Designers use their expertise to fill the world with the shiny and new, but—spoiler alert—don’t always feel so bright-eyed themselves.
ANTS SPIRALING, SOURCE UNKNOWN

ANTS SPIRALING, SOURCE UNKNOWN

Instead of responding with an image that represents our times, one respondent imagined their own: “a group of designers diligently feeding the beast that is corporate capitalist extractive practices obsessed with growth.” Here’s how Dall-E interpreted the prompt:
DALL-E IMAGES GENERATED BY PROMPT

DALL-E IMAGES GENERATED BY PROMPT:
"A GROUP OF DESIGNERS DILIGENTLY FEEDING THE BEAST THAT IS CORPORATE CAPITALIST EXTRACTIVE PRACTICES OBSESSED WITH GROWTH."

For many interviewees, it’s clear that making a mark is not the same as leaving a mark. As Ruben Pater speculates in CAPS LOCK, if consumer capitalism took hold of graphic design, is there a way out? While many people don’t have the privilege of quitting their day jobs or bowing out of commercial projects entirely, respondents are interrogating design as a tool for consumption and their role in perpetuating it.

3.3

DESIGNING FOR
CONSEQUENCES

“[A CHALLENGE FOR ME IS] FINDING
INSPIRATION AND THE POWER TO DESIGN WHEN
EVERYTHING OUTSIDE IS FALLING APART.”

Most designers want to make an impact, but with endless crises to choose from and the limits of awareness tactics, it’s hard to know where to start — especially when free time is a scarce resource. Faced with a world on fire, designers of all kinds are struggling to stay motivated and find fulfillment in a field increasingly beholden to capitalist order. And when your deliverables are things like digital banners or print-ready files, the “client fire” begins to feel superfluous compared to the all-consuming blaze around us.

Some interviewees proposed that finding meaning starts with a critical understanding of design’s role in the systems that brought us here. Designers are claiming responsibility for their work beyond the assignment by asking the tough questions. Even the mental shift from "Sans serif or serif?" to "Does this decision cause harm?" begins to own up to the consequences that design has on the world.
Although the scale of the issues we face is overwhelming, hopeless civic depression doesn’t get us any further than toxic positivity. As in any creative field, hope is essential to inspiration; coming up with brilliant ideas and designing them requires that fuel. The attitude many designers are adopting lands somewhere in the middle of the positivity-doom spectrum: a critical optimism that starts with interrogating design’s role in the systems we want to change.
When it feels as though our world is falling apart, it’s imperative for designers to reject business as usual and reimagine a different future. That we don’t design blindly but work to understand the consequences of every design decision, no matter how small. That we come together to cultivate meaningful relationships and sustainable change. That we encourage client accountability but also come to the table with radical alternatives. The path to thriving futures is murky, but one thing is certain: this isn’t a task for any one designer — it’s a project for us all.

UNRAVEL

1. IS [INSERT DESIGN PROJECT HERE] PERFORMATIVE ACTIVISM?

2. WHAT ARE THE CONSEQUENCES OF [INSERT DESIGN PROJECT HERE]?

3. WHO DOES OUR WORK MATERIALLY BENEFIT? DOES IT CAUSE HARM?

4. WHAT IS THE VALUE IN NOT CREATING SOMETHING?